[Case Study] How We Sold An 18-Month-Old Site For Mid 6 Figures (And The Exact Tactics We Used To Grow It This Fast)

All the numbers shared in this case study have been taken from the official sales document handled by the guys at FE International and have gone through extensive due diligence. It was important for us to have a 3rd party be a guarantee of all the numbers we shared here to avoid the hype that usually plagues this industry. Enjoy the case study :).

We have just sold a site from our portfolio for a very acceptable mid 6 figures amount.

The fun part?

This site was only 18 months old.

Here’s the story of this site and how we got it so high, so quickly…

About 1.5 years ago, we started further expanding our portfolio with new sites, which we did not disclose publicly.

These new sites quickly outpaced our other sites in growth and monetization efficiency early on.

To the point where we decided to focus our effort on these properties instead of our older ones back in May of 2018.

In today’s post, I will share the story of how we started and grew one of those sites and how we sold it for mid 6 figures in just 18 months.

But before we get started, here are some stats for this website so you get an idea of the trajectory we achieved with it in 2018 despite all the Google updates.

image9 1

Authorityhacker graph1

Graph provided by FE International

This site was very much a side project. As a portfolio company, we run a number of sites, not to mention AuthorityHacker.com itself which takes up the majority of our time.

If you want to hear about what else we achieved last year, we’ve recorded a podcast that sums up the year for us.

The Money

I know you guys want to see what the financials of the site looked like when we sold it.

To make it short, the site was making about $15,000/month ($180,000/year) and cost us about $3,500/month ($42,000/year) with content creation, link building and hosting.

I did not add tool costs because we split these costs across our whole portfolio but you could add $200-300/month of tool costs if this was your only business.

Here is the monthly ramp up and P&L for this site:

Commissions Content Link Building Hosting Total
Dec 17 +$210 -$2950 -$530 -$30 -$3300
Jan 18 +$921 -$2950 -$530 -$30 -$2,589
Feb 18 +$971 -$2950 -$530 -$30 -$2,539
Mar 18 +$2,113 -$2950 -$530 -$30 -$1,397
Apr 18 +$3,373 -$2950 -$530 -$30 -$137
May 18 +$4,291 -$2950 -$530 -$30 +$781
Jun 18 +$8,374 -$2950 -$530 -$30 +$4,864
Jul 18 +$10,822 -$2950 -$530 -$30 +$7312
Aug 18 +$12,232 -$2950 -$530 -$30 +$8722
Sep 18 +$13,926 -$2950 -$530 -$30 +$10,416
Oct 18 +$12,736 -$2950 -$530 -$30 +9,226
Nov 18 +$15,692 -$2950 -$530 -$30 +$12,182
Dec 18 +$14,400 -$2950 -$530 -$30 +$10,890
2018 +$100,061 -$38,350 -$6,890 -$390 +$54,431

Let me break down what each line includes.

  • Affiliate Commissions: This is the money that came in each month when you add up all the commissions from all the affiliate offers promoted on the website.
  • Content Creation: This cost includes outsourced content writers, editors, illustrators and any other cost that went into creating what you can see on the site. Content specifically for link building is also included in here.
  • Link Building: Any staff and tool costs associated with acquiring links to the site. Since we don’t pay for links, this cost stayed fairly low.
  • Hosting: Any cost related to serving the files of the site (namely hosting + CDN)

Picking the niche

Because we sold this site and out of respect for the buyer, I can not disclose the exact niche this site is in on this post. I also can not reveal the exact price we sold the site for or any information that would allow you to trace the site back (and trust me I’ve traced a lot of sites back).

Sorry guys.

However, I will go as far as saying that this site is in the software niche.

What I can also share, is how and why we decided to go after this niche.

What was the thought process and how can you apply it to your own niche selection.

How advanced SEO’s should approach niche research

Before I get started, let me say who this process is for.

Mark and I are not beginners anymore and this massively changes the way we approach niche research.

We have done this dozen of times and built many successful sites over the years.

We have also worked in extremely competitive niches such as travel or finance, back when we had our agency.

As a result, we have gained enough self-confidence to know we can do ok in most niches.

If you are a beginner, this process will be significantly different and has been outlined in The Authority Site System.

So if you are just getting started, this part is not for you.

But if you are an advanced marketer, hear me out…

1 – Affiliate Payout

Obligatory Analytics screenshot here showing the traffic growth over 2018, until we listed the site for sale.

image14

But hold on a sec.

We’ve been saying for years that traffic on it’s own doesn’t mean jack. It’s a vanity metric.

What matters is how much money this traffic actually generates for you.

In the past, we’ve built sites that get upwards of half a million monthly visitors.

But despite having just a fraction of the traffic, this site made more money than sites with far more traffic.

Why?

Simple: it makes 6-8x more money per visitor.

This means that need a lot less traffic to make a lot of money

How?

The answer is simple: Affiliate Offers Payout.

The products we promote on this new site generate 30-70% commission rates. Compare that to the Amazon Associates payout rates of 3-8%.

In the affiliate world, the payout disparity is massive.

Some offers will pay you $0.5/lead while others will pay you $1000 per sale.

Authorityhacker illustration 3

These differences are usually indexed on paid traffic competition and value per lead for the company.

If the competition and CPCs are high, the payout is high.

If the competition and CPCs are low, the payout is low.

And to some extent, it does translate to SEO competitiveness as well.

Good luck trying to rank for casino offers related keywords.

These keywords are nasty.

However, for everything between casino offers and Amazon, one thing we have noticed is this:

The variation of SEO difficulty is almost always much lower than the variation of offers payout.

What does this mean in plain English?

It means payouts grow faster than SEO competition and the resources it takes to compete in most niches.

image6

Therefore, as an advanced SEO, it makes more sense to focus on the highest payout niches because you will get more return for your effort despite the increased difficulty.

I hope I don’t change this status quo with this post :/. *expecting some angry emails from friends*.

BUT

This only works if you’re an SEO Sensei. If you are a beginner and you can’t cope with the competition, chances are, you won’t do well in competitive niches.

All of this to say, a large part of our niche research was to identify markets with high earnings per sale and it clearly paid off.

But this wasn’t the only thing we looked at.

2 – Family Friendly

Another important criteria for us was that the niche is family friendly.

I did bring up the idea of the male sexual enhancement niche to Mark a few years ago but he immediately said no because his mom would probably disapprove.

image5 1

Alright.

But more seriously.

We are known to build all our links with white hat outreach and this is what we are good at.

We build links, lots of them, all without paying for them (and actually doing what Google wants webmasters to do).

Here is a snapshot of the site we sold’s link growth.

image7 1

I think we did a pretty a good job especially considering this was not the easiest niche to build links in.

The problem is: If your site is about some kind of weird sex toy or diet pill, almost nobody that’s not compensated will link to you.

And a lot of our core strength falls flat.

For people relying on PBN’s, this is less of an issue, but for us it was important.

3 – The product is not crap

Call me soft if you want but I don’t like making the world a worse place.

Unfortunately, this statement is often incompatible with high payouts.

Many companies pay their affiliates a lot of money to compensate for a shit product.

That’s basically the hot/crazy scale of affiliate marketing.

tenor

Finding one that sells good stuff AND pays well was a challenge, but we managed it.

If your ethical sense is more flexible than ours, once again, this is a non-issue, but not for us, unfortunately.

Another thing I would add to this category is the quality of the product’s sales page.

Many high-quality products have a TERRIBLE sales page.

Sorry, let me rephrase.

TEEEEEERRIBLE.

Here’s an example for an NLP course I would probably stay away from.

image23

4 – Lots of decent volume keywords

Another strength of ours was large content production operations so we knew that we would do better in a niche where traffic is split amongst hundreds of keywords.

Many people struggle with this meaning we have a competitive advantage here.

The final site ended with 240 published pages at the time of sale, most of them targeting decent volume commercial keywords mostly.

image20

5 – Growth over time

Because we never know how long we will hold our businesses, we always want to get involved in niches that are at least stable or growing.

The niche we picked has a steady long-term growth so it was perfect for us as you can see by the Google trends screenshot below.

image18

How we settled for this niche

Once you have put your criteria together, it’s just a matter of looking at niches and see if they tick the boxes.

And that’s exactly what we did.

Every time I browse the web and come across an interesting affiliate or authority site, I bookmark it just in case.

Additionally, multiple sites provide premade affiliate research and/or affiliate program lists.

Here are a few of them.

Premade affiliate researches:

Here are some other cool sites that regularly release niche researches you can use:

You should also check the big affiliate networks and popular independent programs. We made a post dedicated to this too.

 We browsed these and found a niche that ticked all the boxes mentioned above and went for it.

Planning the site

At the time, we had no idea how far we wanted to take this project.

It was more like, let’s see what we get.

When we are in this situation, we like to brand broad so we can expand many categories on the site if it is successful.

So we didn’t just focus on the main software category we planned on publishing.

We went up 1 category level and branded around that.

However, most of our content was developed in the one main subcategory we initially picked.

This is what the sitemap looked like:

image8

The non-developed silos were just a single placeholder page waiting for their turn.

This allowed us to make the navigation consistent with the branding of the domain without having to massively invest in them.

The silo we did decide to develop on the other hand, not only focused on the “easy” keywords but rather took the approach to build a site that covers the topic comprehensively.

This means we did create a lot of pages for keywords we had little chance to rank for in the short and medium term.

But all the top ranking sites had pages targeting these terms so we thought they were important to be seen as a resource on the topic so we made one.

We did, of course, identify the easy keywords and made sure these are developed early so we can get to break even ASAP.

When the planning was done, the site had around 120 pages planned so about 50% of where it’s at at the time of the sale.

If you are advanced and you have the budget, planning your first 100 pages from the get-go really helps you structure a comprehensive resource AND hit easy to rank keywords.

Building The Content

The initial goal we have with every site we start is to get to break even while having a monthly 4 figures investment in it.

Why?

Because when you get to break even, you have time to figure things out, your site pays for itself.

Before that, it drains your bank account.

As mentioned before, we had about 120 pages planned on day 1 and we needed someone to not only put these together but also keep them updated.

We had some funds set apart for the website and an excellent writer, who we had worked with a long time ago in a neighboring niche.

We decided to contact him and see if he was available for a full-time position as the main writer of the website.

Luckily he accepted, thus raising our monthly cost by around $1,900 but giving us the means to get these pages cranked out.

Having a full-time writer allowed us to take the time to really educate him on the product as opposed to a freelancer that may be touching on many different niches.

We bought him all the products we were going to promote and his first task was to get to know them and test them in real life.

This may seem weird to a lot of affiliate marketers who just write content on products just by Googling related keywords or reading sales pages (let’s be honest, most people do that).

But as we did the niche research, we identified that most competitors did that and actually providing fresh insights was a way to stand out and break in this competitive niche.

Unfortunately, I can not reveal what the tests were without revealing the niche but let’s just say these were “real life” tests, a bit like those we do here on Authority Hacker when we test tools.

After about a month of tests, we had produced a bunch of new data we could offer to the industry inside our content so that we stand out for these juicy review keywords.

And that’s exactly what we did.

We started producing and publishing content, building the site hub by hub to quickly gain topical relevance in the subcategories that are live.

image8

This is the editorial strategy we have followed as long as we worked on the site.

There was no content schedule, no drip or anything, just new hubs being released in batches as we worked through content creation sprints.

I remember publishing 12 articles per day some days then nothing for 2 weeks.

As this was more of an SEO game than a “following” game, nobody was really watching when we publish new content and really Google doesn’t seem to care that much about dripped vs batch published content as long as it’s good.

Building Links

Now that we had the core of our site, the domain needed some links.

Remember, this was a competitive industry and without a serious amount of links, no way the site would take off.

When we looked at the competition, we identified 2 distinct factors within the sites that did really well in the industry:

1 – Volume

All the top sites have 500-10,000 linking root domains.

Not all links are top quality but they all do have a certain volume of semi-related links. In order to compete, we had to get as close to this number as possible as soon as possible.

2 – High DR Links

All the top sites have done a substantial PR effort to get links from high-end sites like CNN, Huffington Post, Wikipedia etc.

So in order to compete for the big keywords, we could not just rely on usual low-end SEO tactics most people used.

We had to find a way to appear on these sites with a brand new domain.

I like challenges :).

Achieving Volume

Volume link building is what we are known for. If you are part of Authority Hacker Pro or The Authority Site System, you have probably heard about our Shotgun Skyscraper link building approach.

We applied it to this site and, surprise surprise, it worked like a charm.

We built about 500 linking root domains in 2018 to the domain.

image10

The “volume” links are a mix of Skyscraper, broken links and spontaneous outreach to sites in our field.

In short, we analyzed the competition with Ahrefs (review) and identified which pages had generated the most links for them, then we just created a page on the same topic while making sure the research and production value was top notch including infographics, videos etc.

Then we promoted this content by emailing the people that already linked to our competitors and other people ranking for the main keywords of the content asking them to link to it.

We used Mailshake (review) for the outreach process and continuously optimized our templates using their A/B testing features.

If you want to see an in-depth look at exactly how we used the Shotgun Skyscraper process to build so many links, we have some great content around that coming out soon. Make sure to subscribe to be among the first to be notified when this is released.

The site really started taking off when we hit 200 linking root domains which seems to correlate with the number of links we saw the competitors doing well having.

Achieving High DR Links

Achieving link volume is only one part of the equation.

If your site only has a large volume of low DR sites, search traffic does rise initially but you often plateau growth if you just stick to just that.

As we began to notice this scenario to this new site, we decided to develop a new effort to get high-end links and balance the volume of lower authority links.

This leads us to start with remodeling our guest posting approach as it was the most obvious tactic we could use for high DR links.

From now on, Guest Posting would serve the following purposes in our overall link building strategy:

  • Acquire High DR links to achieve more balance in our link building strategy
  • Acquire direct links to our non-skyscraper content
  • Get the exact match anchor text that’s hard to get in other forms of link building

Because they were part of the high DR links branch of our link building, we only focused on high DR and/or high relevancy sites. So we didn’t just write to any site with a “write for us” page like most people do when they talk about guest posting.

We set the bar to DR 55 at least and made sure the sites had real traffic and/or did not get hit by any kind of Google updates in the past 2 years.

How did we find these sites?

Well, we had several tactics.

The first one was painfully simple:

We pitched a guest post to the people that said no to our other link building tactic approaches and that matched the metrics we were looking for:

image12 1

You’d be surprised at how many people that said no to other approaches said yes to this one.

The second tactic we used is just emailing relevant sites and ask them to post on their sites.

Not sites that advertise guest posts.

Not even sites that have accepted guest posts in the past.

Just sites in the same niche as ours.

image16

But we did not just use guest posts to get high DR links.

Another fairly easy way to get high DR links is to reply to HARO requests.

What is HARO? Glad you asked.

HARO stands for “Help a Reporter Out” and is basically a service that journalists can use to ask for expert quotes.

Basically, you sign up for a mailing list over here and receive 2 emails daily that looks like this

image11

You then craft a well put together response to relevant requests in the list, email it to the journalist while including 1 or 2 links to your site in there and hope for the best.

If you want to join these newsletters, you can sign up for in on their homepage.

There are several tactics to get picked up more often but these probably should be in their own post.

But since you’re here I will give you some pointers:

  1. Work on your about page, make it highlight all the cool stuff you have done in the industry and link to it in your intro/signature when you reply.
  2. Have a face photo when you reply.
  3. Don’t just link to your stuff in your responses. Add 1-2 links to your site and 3-4 links to other resources.
  4. Have a strong branding and produce original tests/content
  5. Reply quickly. The faster your reply, the more likely you will get the link.

Since we had demonstrated authority on our site with our Skyscraper content, it was easy to get taken seriously and get quotes with links on very high DR sites.

Growing Revenue Faster

If you check the revenue graph I sent earlier, you see pretty drastic jumps in revenue at some points.

Authorityhacker graph1

How did we achieve that?

Well, the SEO outlined earlier did achieve the linear growth you see.

But the growth bursts were achieved in a much simpler way.

We just asked.

That’s right.

Once you show growing monthly revenue to companies whom you promote. It’s very easy to go and say you want to work more seriously together and offer to create more content related to their product.

Very often, companies will ask you to push their products more favorably in exchange for higher commissions.

This is not something we wanted to do but managed to double our commissions anyway, just by asking.

Another thing that ensured continuous growth is the way we added new content to the site.

Every time a specific content angle was doing well in search and converting, we basically produced content for every keyword with at least 50 search volume following the same template.

So for example, if it was a “X vs Y” keyword that ended up banking, we created all “X vs Y” articles we could with at least 50 search volume, regardless of the competition level.

We also published the content as soon as it was ready once again.

No drip schedule, no content calendar.

Some days I would publish 12 articles at once.

We followed this tactic as long as we had the site.

Deciding to sell

If this site did so well, why the Hell did you decide to sell?

Good question.

To be frank we were not 100% sure we were going to sell this site until very recently.

We knew we were at crossroads.

Either sell and start something new or double down to maintain the growth.

This project so far had very much been a side project. I spent max 3-4 days/month on it and we were really hitting the point where to get much bigger, we’d probably need to overhaul a lot of the website.

That meant less time on the other sites in our portfolio and, more importantly, less time to focus on Authority Hacker.

Furthermore, the fact we had achieved such rapid growth meant that if we were to sell now, our return compared to the time invested would be very high.

As a result, we decided to “see what we can get” with site brokers.

It was a good opportunity to cash out if we got an interesting offer, free up time for the other things we need to work on and inject cash flow into something that could use it.

So we took our chances and sent the site to a few brokers.

Working with Brokers and M&A Firms

So after deciding to see what we can get for this site, we contacted 2 brokers and 1 M&A firm.

It was interesting to get a first-hand experience with them.

We have sold an online business before, but not a content site through a broker/advisor.

There is a process here, which varies depending on who you work with. First, you will be in touch with a valuation expert from the brokerage or M&A firm.

They will ask a number of questions about your business, including requiring a profit and loss statement for the last 12 months, broken down by month (they will provide a template if you do not have this already).

The number the valuation department will give you is based on their interpretation of how valuable your business is based on similar sales.

They look at a lot of hard metrics such as:

  • Monthly traffic
  • Revenue in the past 3, 6, 12 months
  • Time spent by the owner
  • Costs
  • Transferability of the business
  • Growth curve
  • Price of sites in the same industry sold in the past 6 months

But they also apply a lot of subjective factors to the valuation.

Things like:

  • The quality of your backlinks
  • The quality of your content
  • The potential “peak” of your site

And this is where things vary wildly from broker to broker (and M&A advisor).

Good firms will find the number that is realistic to sell for. Be careful of those who over-inflate valuations (to get you to work with them) or under-value (to make it an easier deal for them).

But some valuations from the biggest brokers were less than half of the price we got for the site in the end.

I know you want me to name and shame them but to be honest I don’t think it would be fair as this is a single occurrence and it might not be reflective of how their business runs in other cases.

Let’s just say I HIGHLY recommend you get several valuations before you jump in with a broker.

You will probably be leaving a lot of money on the table if you don’t.

In the end, the M&A team over at FE International ended up giving us a valuation we were happy to go with and they had a really good understanding of the effort that was put into the site.

Both in terms of content and links.

Because the site had quite a big growth curve and then stabilized in the last 2 months. They have based the valuation with a heavier weighting on the past 6 months instead of the past 12 months like most brokers do.

I asked Thomas, the Founder of FE International what they liked so much about the site to provide a higher valuation (than we got elsewhere) and he said:

Unlike many websites people are trying to sell on lower quality marketplaces and smaller brokers, [the website] had extremely high-quality content and link profile – something serious buyers recognize and are willing to pay a premium for. The traffic had been on an upward growth trajectory, alongside the revenue which was growing each month.


With the high-quality content and links we were confident the site had reached a new baseline of traffic and income and would not decline which would be more likely if it had been using a PBN or lower quality links. This gave us and eventually, buyers, a lot of faith that it would be a solid investment, justifying an above-average multiple.


We have been following and recommending the Authority Hacker course to our clients for a number of years – Gael and Mark walk the walk and are masters of what they do.”

Thomas Smale, Founder of FE International

image24

In our case, we had some higher costs in the months leading up the sale. These were R&D type costs. We were developing a new content type that wasn’t deployed yet.

This made the valuation more difficult, but we were able to talk with FE and get them to understand it. They didn’t penalize our valuation for such costs.

More details on the SDE basis of valuation: https://feinternational.com/blog/how-do-you-value-an-online-business/

I want to highlight that to make the valuation easier, you need everything to be clean and in order in your business.

You will need to provide proof of everything you claim via a secure data room.

That includes:

  • Reports/screenshots of all affiliate earnings in the affiliate area AND payments on your bank accounts
  • Written confirmation that customer commission bumps would be passed to the new owner from the product companies (negotiate that at the same time as commission bumps if you might sell one day)

This can be complicated for example if you have multiple sites promoting the same program and you sell just one of them. You really want clear tracking ID’s to split the revenue of each site and track things properly.

They put together a detailed 15-20 page prospectus, which has a bunch of key data, numbers and summary of the business. It was really quite good.

On our end it was mostly about answering a lot of questions and providing things like Google analytics access and proofs of income.

The team at FE International then took that information and put the prospectus together to send to a vetted list of potential target buyers. We were asked to approve this for factual accuracy and to ensure they had correctly understood the business before it went out.

Then the M&A team took over. They have a three-phased approach to marketing the business. They first go out to their A-List. These are people they know and trust who have expressed specific interest in a site that is similar to the one you are selling. Likely many have bought sites before. We got several serious inquiries from this group.

The second phase is expanding the target list to a wider group from their 41,000+ investor network. They did not spam the list, rather selectively found other buyers that could be a fit – these were used to leverage the buyers from the first group (very successfully!)

The third phase (which we never got to due to the speed of the deal!) is promoting on third-party marketplaces/platforms for additional demand and interest.

Quickly after getting started, we had one call with a guy who made an offer below list price.

Then had another call with a buyer who was really interested and offered above asking price due to the amount of interest we received.

FE then negotiated terms and a Letter of Intent was drafted and signed. The buyer then started their due diligence (most of this was completed in the pre-listing due diligence phase which saved a lot of time and effort and kept the process moving).

During the latter stages of buyer due diligence, FE’s legal team starts drafting the ‘Asset Purchase Agreement’ which involves legal clarifications mainly around the assets being acquired and the practical elements of the transfer. Both sides got to review and comment on this until there was an agreement.

During this process, FE continues to market the business to ensure buyers do not re-negotiate terms or hold up the process. You never feel like you have left any value on the table.

In the meantime, another buyer emerged with 7-figures to invest.

They were aware the site was in due diligence. Because they were a strategic buyer (means they were in the same industry), the site was worth a lot more to them.

So they made an offer even higher than the second offer. This was the one which we ended up proceeding with.

It was quite a dramatic few days. Mark was on holiday in Egypt and was rushing back from the pyramids to do calls.

Mark in Egypt

In the end, the strategic buyer was able to sign the asset purchase agreement quickly with FE coordinating throughout.

The next steps of the transfer are escrow. We used Escrow.com. The buyer and seller split the fees.

image22

FE set up the transaction via their official partner account and the buyer transfers money to Escrow.com. Escrow.com secures the funds and instructed us to transfer the assets.

We worked with FE to prepare a handover document and we then begin transferring the domain, site, processes, team, affiliate accounts etc. Affiliate accounts were tricky as we still have to receive the payouts up to the time when we sold the site.

So, it’s important to maintain a good relationship with the buyer here. Also, it’s a small community, and you never know who you will be dealing with again.

It’s in everyone’s interest for the site to grow after you sell it, so we did everything we could after the sale to make this happen.

After it was all transferred, the escrow was released. FE get their cut and we get the remaining minus our share of the escrow fees.

As we are a UK company, and the transaction was in USD, it made sense for us to use a transfer company. Transferwise is an option, though in this case, we used our Business Revolut account.

It’s always a good idea to contact your bank or transfer company in advance to let them know you will be receiving a large transfer. We had to provide additional documentation to show where the money was coming from and was it was from. This is common for large transfers.

pasted image 0

Now that everything is done and we have been paid, I’m excited to see what the new owner does with the site.

After talking to them, I know they are really experienced and given how strong the content and link base is on this site, I’m not worried at all.

After all, this site cruised smoothly through 2018 so it should be fine.

So What Did We Learn?

This site has been a great experience to work on.

We really enjoyed the niche and really got to know it in a deeper way which was a lot of fun.

It was also one of the first sites we started after releasing The Authority Site System and it was built EXACTLY following what’s inside the course just to make sure the approach was still the best.

I guess it did alright.

So do we regret selling it now?

*looks at bank account*

Nah.

Actually, this made us want to build more sites with the goal of selling them 1 – 2 years later and we have a lot more to invest back into building additional sites following a similar formula

It does not mean we will only build sites to sell.

But our friend Matt Diggity does this extensively with Leadspring with great success and I think we can do something similar.

We have already started to work on a new batch of websites within this project and with all the learnings we have had from this site, I am quite confident we can do it again multiple times.

I know we haven’t been the best at updating you on our progress in 2018 and some of you even doubted the authority site model was still a good one with the last batch of updates.

But I can guarantee you it is alive and kicking and those who are spending time mastering it are doing very well for themselves.

What did you think about this story?

Did it motivate you to start or grow your sites?

Did it feel overwhelming and out of reach?

Let us know in the comment section below!

If you want more details on this case study, Mark and I recorded a podcast where we talk about the whole experience, from picking the niche to receiving the money, here is the episode:

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pocket
Share on email
Share on print

Do You Want To Learn How To Build 6 Figure Authority Sites?​

Subscribe to join our FREE training and…

  • Learn how to build white hat links to your site without headaches
  • Finally have a proven method to finding profitable niches
  • Get access to our foolproof keyword research methods
  • Learn how to outsource high quality content

92 Comments

  1. This is a terrific case study! As a “numbers guy” I look at the traffic graphs and wonder why they seem to have such a regular “heart-beat” pattern. It would appear that you get nearly constant traffic during the week, and then it drops by a fairly consistent amount every weekend. In the middle area (summer-time?) things look more erratic although they continue to steadily grow, then that “heart-beat” pattern resumes. It’s surprising to me that there’s such a regular pattern. Do you know and/or can you share what causes this?

  2. Amazing article, usually I do not trust this kind of post I have been working on SEO and affiliate for over 3 years I can smell the shit with just a few lines. And honestly looks this study case looks amazing I will save it in my bookmarks

    1. Thanks Roman,

      This means a lot :). I agree with most of these posts being B.S, that’s why we had a 3rd party put the numbers together and a buyer vetted them so it doesn’t all come from our mouth.

  3. Thanks for posting this!

    I actually started a fantasy sports content website at the start of the daily fantasy boom. I eventually sold it 2 years ago but not for 6-figures. I had it making about $2,000 – $3,500 a month.

    By the time I sold it was hyper-competitive which is part of the reason I decided to get out.

    Reading this post makes me want to jump into something else and do it all over again.

  4. Great stuff Mark and Gael, really impressed and inspired by your case study. I wanted to know if you wrote for the website under your own names or a pen name? Is there a benefit/drawback to using a pen name?

    Also, where did you get the other kind of content created from, namely videos, infographics etc?

  5. Which country is your writer from? Also, how can you be sure that they were, in fact, working full-time (40 hours a week) on your site only?

  6. Hi guys,

    Congrats for your success on this. I’m a fan of your podcast for more than 2 years now.

    You said that you spend 3/4 days a month on this site and I’m really impressed by this figure.

    I mean writing 120 pages with quality article take a bunch of time even if you outsource it then you need to format it, make it SEO ready, create visual, video and publish it.

    So I’m thinking that you should have some template or trick you could share in a future post, like how to make your content writing, SEO, and publishing frictionless and mostly automatic.

    I personally spend tons of time on my startup project I beginning with a website where I create content and bring around 20 000 visitors per month in the nutrition niche(Get badly hit by Medic update) and then decided to launch a nutrition app related to that niche.

    I’m really impressed because for now we have generated traffic and interest but not money like you seems to have done with only 3/4 days a month…

    Our goal is not really to make an authority site but more a startup product but in a way you need to be an authority in your niche to be successful.

    So congrats to that !

  7. Great article you guys, and congrats on the sale as well!

    I was wondering since the sale means you basically give up the business to the other person, does that mean that you gave up the staff that did the work as well? I mean, were the writer and your link builders also a part of the deal, thus ended up with a new boss? Or do you just gave up the SOPs for the new owner to find and train his own teams?

    Thank you very much!

  8. Great article guys.
    One question:
    So, once a site is generating a certain amount of monthly profit, why would one not just keep it going since the content is ranking and generating income? Does this require a constant monetary investment after content is ranking? If so, what investment would that be, aside from hosting fees, if you could just update existing articles over time? What regular expenses can one expect once a site is generating a profit? Thanks!

    Has the model changed to a less passive one?

    1. Hey Frank,

      In competitive niches, your competitors are always watching you and trying to snag your keywords, outrank you etc. You do need to keep link building ahead of the competition or they can overtake you. How much you need to spend does depend on them really. Mostly I’d say as online marketing is getting more competitive, the passive aspect is going away.

      1. Therefore, building the website is one effort that done right could take for example 18 months, and keeping it going would just mean maintaining that effort. It’s an ongoing job, guys!

  9. Excellent post, I have already shared it with a friend that is looking to learn more.

    I specifically liked seeing how much you put into it each month, and what you were getting out. You were negative for months, I think a lot of people don’t realize what it takes.

    Congratulations, and I wish to be on your level in the future.

    One question, you don’t pay for links, how do you respond to a webmaster that asks for payment? Just scratch them off the list?

    1. Hey Steven,

      Glad you liked the post.

      Depending on their response we try to negotiate to still get a link. Whether that’s offering a guest post, trying to provide some other kind of value or w/e it takes.

  10. Hey guys, amazing case study! Just curious, did you guys build an email list to sell the product, or did all the sales come from links within the content itself like those used in amazon affiliate products.

    Hope the question is okay to ask, otherwise, I understand.

  11. Hi Gael,

    Congratulations and well done guys! Very Very good work!

    Your article is very long and I am sure that you put lots of effort in it. But from my experience the devil is in the detail. Everything that you wrote is a common practice and I am quite sure that you put your own “unique” spin on that which made all the huge difference. I am quite aware of your contractual obligations and the fact that you don’t want to reveal all your secrets – perfectly understandable.

    It would be interesting to know what happened between May and June – you’ve doubled your income.
    Also traffic doubled in October but revenue remained flat – this is very interesting.
    It’s also interesting to note that while traffic was more or less stable earning went up – was is just a good luck or something else?
    What was the valuation multiple – it sounds like it was around 30 – is this correct?

    I am aware that you have your own contractual obligations but it would be good to get more info.

    My personal guess is that you’ve acquired extremely high DR links in a very competitive sub niche and this made much of the difference. How you acquired those links it’s anyone’s guess. Writing great content is fairly easy (if you have the right people) But it’s worthless without having great links.

    I would be extremely skeptical that you got your links using these tactics. As an example I know someone who owns a DA 70 site – every day he gets around 30-40 emails similar to your’s (with various variations) why would this guy pick your offer. I have a few guesses based on the various offers he gets but I would keep these ideas to myself.

  12. awesoem case study Gael.
    I am dying hard to create a site like yours and earn lots of dollars like you :)
    I read whole article. You didnt reveal the niche and the site :(

  13. Thanks,
    Gael for all the work,

    This is the Second time I comment on this website but this website is where I get the inspiration and the tactic for my affiliate. just two questions,
    1- what is the average return for you shotgun skyscraper tactic.
    2- also what is the email idea that you send to get those links do you ask for a link or just plan content promotion ??

    would love to see some article about it (shotgun skyscraper)

  14. Hi Gael,

    That was a very inspiring and excellent writeup.
    I would love for you guys to write an article on how you both set up your business and banks to deal with these website projects as no one in the IM or SEO community ever talks about the backend.

    For example, is it best to dedicate a site to its own separate business or have it all under one company?

    Would be a great read and think a lot of beginners will get a lot of value from.

    1. Hey Onder,

      Glad you liked the article, I’ll try to get Mark to do this one as he is the one handling it.

  15. Hi Gael,

    That was a very inspiring and excellent writeup.
    I would love for you guys to write an article on how you both set up your business and banks to deal with these website projects as no one in the IM or SEO community ever talks about the backend.

    For example, is best to dedicate a site to its own separate business or have it all under one business?

    Would be a great read and think a lot of beginners will get a lot of value from.

  16. I have been following your site for six months, this post is amazing! It helps me a lot.

    Thank you and keep it up.

  17. That’s a good article but i have doubts of my own regarding authenticity of this article as the name of niche nor website is disclosed; the graphs and images displayed here on this articles can always be created using photoshop i guess. I want to buy this course and i am expecting more transparency, hope i am not asking for much.

    Thank you

    1. Hi Flynn,

      I understand but legalities are what they are. The good news is all the numbers in this post are backed up by FE International (they even reshared it on their FB page https://www.facebook.com/FEinternational/posts/2214843635291241 and emailed it to their list), they are the biggest site broker in the industry and I doubt they would jeopardize their credibility for a fake case study. Hopefully, this gives you trust in the numbers we were able to share.

  18. When you mentioned, “So for example, if it was a “X vs Y” keyword that ended up banking, we created all “X vs Y” articles”

    Were these articles created solely for internal linking purposes?

    Thanks

    1. Hey Troy,

      No, they were created to maximize revenue. If one article was making money, we wanted to show up for all similar keywords.

  19. Congratulations guys, wondering where you hired the fixed salary full time staff for this website. Looks like you got a reasonable salary for a full time writer here.

    Appreciate any thoughts on where to find that.

    Thanks

    1. Hey Fede,

      In this case it was lucky, we worked with that guy before on an old project but usually, Upwork and the ProBlogger job board is where we hire from.

  20. Congrats on the Sale! When you say you build close to 500 RD´s – Close to your competitors,

    Did you have-maintain any specific link velocity ?

    People like Matt tell us to do things like a social signal blast and then build links-Build Links at a velocity that justifies the page´s traffic-For eg, If a page gets like 500 visits a day then build like 15-20 links a month and for a page that gets lower traffic build less links so that it is justified-Build Less links to e commerce or product pages as it´s not natural to have a lot of links to such pages. What are your thoughts on this ?

    This is the part that confuses me the most. Which Guru/method to follow ? Brian Dean(Tells us to link from a power page aka skyscraper ) never talks about any of the stuff Matt Diggity Talks (Anchor Text analysis-social signals-link justification etc).

    Please explain what you exactly did. BTW, I´m a member of TASS and i don´t think you covered this in the course.

    1. Hey Mohit,

      Thanks. We don’t really work on velocity but we have ongoing outreach going on so there is a natural throttle in link acquisition happening due to operations.

      In the end, all methods can work, don’t overthink it, just build some links and publish content.

  21. Excellent article Gael and a HUGE Congratulations!!
    I have scheduled to share this one on my 9,000+ Facebook Group on March 2nd.
    Just a few questions:
    1. What was your cost of content?
    2. Did you have/Do you follow a specific anchor text ratio?

    1. Hey Russ,

      Thanks for sharing the article :)

      Here is the answer to your questions:

      1 – We had a full time writer so it depends on how much he was writing this month (check the table in the article)
      2 – no.

  22. Congrats on the sale. I had one question. How many articles did the full-writer manage to complete each month? How many words on average? I’m thinking of hiring a full-time writer myself, but I just don’t know how many articles will a full-time position translate into.

    Don’t get me wrong; I’m well aware that it depends a lot on the writer, the niche and 100’s of other things. I just want to know a rough range of words per month someone working full-time might be able to achieve.

    Thanks a lot for your time.

    1. It’s not that simple. Some articles took a lot of time, others not, others required a lot of research. So I can’t really give a number like it’s a machine and any number I’d give you would just not translate into your business anyway :/.

  23. Great piece of content Gael, thanks!
    It was a branded website I guess. Did you use Author/s in your articles? They were real or fake personas? If the last, did you hand over them to the buyer?

    1. Hey Yolanda,

      Thanks, glad you liked the case study :).

      Yep the website was branded basically exactly the way we teach it in TASS. It also had a fake persona that was handed over to the buyer.

  24. It was amazing. I recently started following this site and now I am thinking that I missed too much value. BTW amazing case study I love that.

    1. We have our own in house staff doing link building so the cost is the cost of their pro-rated salary and the cost of tools and API’s.

  25. Hey Gael!

    This is inspiring no doubt! I’m in the TASS course and of course you guys teach us to monetize with AMZ first.

    I noticed you mention you were promoting multiple products. Did you have to sign up to multiple different affiliate programs?

    Usually doing “best x for y” posts means you are reviewing different products within those posts.

    Does it make things more complicated having to keep track of commissions on multiple networks and having different payout days vs. Amazon where you can see all of your commissions in one place?

    1. Hey Lashay,

      Yep, AMZ is a good place to start, but we are not exactly starting up ourselves anymore so we have slightly different rules applying to us.

      Yep, we were signed up to dozens of different programs.

      And yep it makes tracking more complicated but it’s still worth it :).

  26. You mentioned you don’t pay for links. Would you please clarify what are the monthly costs in the column “Link building”?

  27. Hey Gael, awesome case study! It is highly encouraging. One question if I may ask, did you go with a brand new branded domain or did you purchase older, perhaps dropped one?

    Thanks guys, you rock!

  28. When you mentioned software affiliate offers are you more talking about tools or programs? (e.g. like the NLP training course?)
    (I know it’s not your niche but would love your 2 cents on this!)

  29. Hey

    I’ve heard your name mentioned a few times in groups I’m part of. Now I can see why!

    You mentioned you do a lot of link building. Do you still get links with sites that have footprints like ‘write for us’ or ‘guest post’, or are these super dangerous in 2019?

    Cheers
    Alex

    1. Hey Alex, thanks for dropping by :).

      We do get some links from these sites if their metrics and traffic looks good. But we wouldn’t go for any site that advertises they take guest posts.

  30. Great Outcome!
    Just want to clarify this if So you’re saying you build all links to your root domain/homepage only?

    if not, in this case study how many links were pointed or acquired to the homepage vs inner pages?

    Thanks

  31. Thanks for putting in the time for this write up. It’s interesting to look into the world of website flipping.

    Where would you suggest would be a good place to buy your first websites? And is there a difference in marketplaces once you start stepping up to these larger websites?

    Thanks in advance!

    1. Hey Michael,

      For the best places, I’d say it depends on your experience and budget. If you are very experienced, there still are gems to be picked up on Flippa for cheap. If you need more guarantees, vetted marketplaces like FEInternational and Empire Flippers are probably a better place.

  32. Congrats guys, well done. Goes to show that affiliate marketing is serious business and should be treated as such. If it’s not confidential, may I ask what FEI takes as a commission? Is it a percentage, a fixed fee or something more complicated?

    Also, did you monetize the site with affiliate products only, or also ads? If no ads, I’d be curious to know your thought process behind that. Thanks guys.

    1. Hey AJ,

      Thanks :)

      FE takes a small % of the overall deal value for arranging everything.

      And yes, the site was only monetized with affiliate offers, mostly because they paid so well it was not worth sending clicks anywhere else.

  33. Great case study and congrats on the sale! Wondering, if you had kept it 6 or more months, could you have sold it for mid to high six-figures instead of low because the valuation would have been much higher? Any reason you didn’t wait and hold on for 6 more months?

    1. Hey Stacy,

      The reason we sold is most of the recent growth had been attributed to the baseline of the site due to the quality of the links and content. So even if we maintained the current revenue we would have had a valuation that was not too far from what we got.

  34. Wow! Congrats Gael and Mark!!

    I always thought I would build an authority site as a long term passive-income investment, but after reading this, I want to build websites with the goal of selling them!
    You guys are such an inspiration!

    Thanks,
    Nate

    1. Hey Nate,

      Thanks :). Yeah we used to be the hold forever guys but to be frank there are pivot points where selling makes sense and I think we will do more of it in the future.

  35. Hi Great insights here.

    How did you manage to keep the costs the same every month?

    How much were you guys willing to invest before seeing a breakeven point?

    1. How did we manage to keep costs the same: We had full-time staff on fixed salaries

      As for how much we were willing to invest, hard to say, I think if we were not break even at 75k in I’d have started to look around.

  36. Great case study Gael, and congrats on the sale!

    Did you plan for this site to be monetised from affiliate commissions only from the beginning or were there any intentions of producing your own product at any point?

  37. Hi,

    Congrats for achieving this amazing feat.
    I wanted to ask, whether you were promoting only a single product on the site or multiple products?

  38. Link building seems to have become one of the most important activities for any website. Content and link building is where any blogger should invest their time. It should only be content but given the quality issues and competition link building became just as important as the content itself. Congrats on the sale!

  39. Really loved the case study :)

    I just wanted to ask you that Have you defined whole silo pages in starting of the site? Like you had something in mind that what type of keywords would you target? And because the site was in software niche, Have you targeted the products which were paying you high commision only? and What types of articles generated good revenue?

    It would be great help :) and keep sharing good stuff.

    Thanks!
    Aakash Patel

  40. Great insights, Gael. Your link building process is impressive and consistent. I will definitely try out some of the tips that you shared, especially that on securing high DR links, for a few of my sites that I believe have plateaued in the last couple of months.

  41. Are your silo pages just simple category pages or regular posts/pages with manual links to the sub-articles? If the latter, do you not publish the category archives? Curious how this structure works in practice with WP.

    1. The silo pages were custom pages and the category pages were redirected to them. But nowadays we directly edit archive pages with Elementor PRO.

  42. Wow Gael, excellent article. Even if the site is not mentioned I didn’t think it needed to be.

    “Did it motivate you to start or grow your sites?”

    Most defiantly.

    I look forward to the next one.

    Congrats
    Mark!

    1. Hey Mark,

      Thanks for dropping by! Glad you enjoyed the case study, we tried to share as much as possible while also respecting the buyer and not creating extra competition for him :).

  43. Wow, awesome case study guys.

    When you said, “If the competition and CPCs are high, the payout is high. If the competition and CPCs are low, the payout is low. And to some extent, it does translate to SEO competitiveness as well.”

    Is this something that is true for promoting Amazon affiliate specifically as well?
    or its true just for the other 30-70% affiliate programs?

      1. Ah, okay!

        But do you think there’s even a (slight) correlation between CPCs in search and amazon payouts?

        Because I’m thinking of using the “traffic value” metric from ahrefs to figure out which are the most profitable keywords and then filter them after analyzing the SEO competition. Do you think there’s any value in this?

  44. Nice case study, Gael!

    Last year after attending the webinar with Perrin (HerePup website case study), I began to apply the business model you taught.

    Result in summary form: 12 months later, I am billing around 5.4k a month (in Brazilian currency, here in Brazil). The site is generating about 150k of monthly traffic.

    The expectation is to increase the yields and strength of the domain. Thanks for the case study. It keeps us even more motivated.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
Copy link